Based on a play about the last chapter in the life of John Wilmot, the 2nd Earl of Rochester, The Libertine makes no excuses about it being a seriously arty farty movie — it retains a play-like structure, where characters spout lines steeped in Olde English and put forth performances with a theatricality not often seen in less serious films.
Recounting how the Earl (Johnny Depp) gradually loses favour with King Charles II (John Malkovich), as well as his tumultuous affair with stage actress Elizabeth Barry (Samantha Morton), The Libertine is not an easy film to watch. Johnny Depp puts forth a markedly different performance when compared to his charming Captain Jack Sparrow (in Pirates of the Caribbean), and really proves his acting chops playing the intense Wilmot, particularly in the last 30 minutes of the film.
Samantha Morton also deserves praise for her spirited portrayal of Elizabeth Barry, and whilst no one in the movie is truly likeable, there is still a lot of acting talent on display that will satisfy the hardcore cineastes. For moviegoers who prefer their films light and easy, this may not be the best choice for a night out.